
What the new DWP fiduciary guidance means for your scheme: ESG and trustee actions
On 5 November 2026, the DWP published its consultation on draft guidance on "Pension fund investment: fiduciary and related duties of trustees" (produced in collaboration with an independent cross-industry working group).
We consider the draft guidance from an ESG perspective, and the actions trustees should be considering now.
In brief: what you need to know
The guidance is intended to give trustees of occupational trust-based schemes greater clarity and confidence about what the law in practice "requires and permits" when applying their existing fiduciary and investment duties.
Importantly, it does not change trustees’ legal duties (including in relation to disclosure, reporting or compliance), but rather seeks to explain how they should operate in modern and emerging investment contexts. It explains key existing concepts relevant to investment decision-making, including acting in “the best interests of members” and taking account of “financially material considerations”, sets out questions and considerations that trustees should have, and gives an Annex of practical examples.
The publication complements and builds on regulatory guidance, including TPR's General Code, with which schemes will already be familiar. We have previously explored what TPR's expectations meant for trustees when considering ESG as part of their investment strategy.
What does the guidance mean for your ESG approach?
The guidance does not propose a new ESG duty - but reinforces the importance of ESG to sustainability and to risk/return over time. It aims to give trustees clarity and greater confidence that existing fiduciary and investment duties can accommodate consideration of long-term sustainability factors, including climate change, nature and biodiversity, and wider system-level risks, provided trustees reasonably consider them financially material.
- The increased emphasis on system-level risks recognises that financial materiality can arise at asset, portfolio, system or whole-economy level, and that trustees may need to consider both how systemic developments affect their investments, and how their investments may themselves contribute to systemic risks or opportunities. The guidance emphasises the long-term perspective, looking at the lifetime of the scheme and of members, as well as the investment holding period.
- It warns that uncertainty is not a reason for excluding a potentially significant issue. Where ESG risks may be difficult to price, trustees are expressly encouraged to use qualitative evidence as part of their assessment, rather than treating the absence of quantitative measures as meaning there is no material risk.
- Cost of living: the guidance explores whether members’ future costs and living circumstances can themselves be financially material. Trustees may take these into account where they reasonably identify a credible connection between an investment decision and members’ retirement outcomes, although the guidance stresses that this remains a matter of trustee judgment and proportionality. This is potentially significant when considering issues such as energy costs, climate resilience, health or other systemic economic effects.
- Engagement and public-policy stewardship: the draft expressly contemplates collaboration with other stakeholders where that is proportionate and serves member interests, and recognises engagement with policymakers, regulators and other public bodies as a potentially legitimate stewardship technique (where the issue is financially material and the engagement is appropriate and cost-effective).
- Application to endgame: the inclusion of master trust transfers, consolidations, buy-ins and buy-outs within the guidance is noteworthy. Where long-term sustainability or other system-level factors are financially material to the decision or choice of provider or insurer, trustees should consider those factors as part of their proportionate fiduciary decision-making framework.
The emphasis of the messaging is therefore on evidence, proportionality, advice, stewardship and a robust decision-making process (rather than prescribing particular ESG investment outcomes).
What you should do now
The guidance as it stands does not require wholesale revision of arrangements, nor does it aim to challenge existing approaches. Trustees should, however, keep the development of this guidance under review. Once finalised, the Government expects trustees and those supporting them to have regard to it where relevant to their decisions – and it is considering whether it might eventually be placed on a statutory footing. The pensions industry is still considering the draft guidance, so we may yet see some changes, but when finalised, the guidance should be embedded into scheme investment governance processes.
Key trustee action points are governance and process-related, rather than new compliance requirements. You should ensure that:
- your investment governance is capable of identifying and properly evaluating climate, sustainability and other long-term and systemic factors where they are financially material.
- your approach is proportional, considering your scheme's particular nature and circumstances.
- your decisions are supported by evidence and appropriate advice.
- you engage with, oversee, and are prepared to question advisers and managers.
- you check your investment adviser and manager oversight to understand respective responsibilities.
- as ever, your decision-making process is well documented, with a clear audit trail of minutes and investment papers recording the material factors considered, relevant advice and the reasons for decisions taken.
Stewardship is contemplated as a key part of investment decision-making, so, you may also want to consider whether your investment and stewardship objectives are implemented effectively, for example, voting and other engagement being used to address financially material risks and opportunities. Pooled and delegated investment arrangements may need particular care and guidance.
Consider what training needs you have here, and take appropriate advice on how best to apply the guidance to your investment decisions, including revising your Statement of Investment Principles and supporting policies against the approach set out in the final guidance.
Amanda Cooke, Partner in TLT's Pensions team, commented:
“The draft gives trustees greater confidence that ESG, sustainability and wider systemic risks can form part of fiduciary decision-making where financially material. Stewardship is a key part of this, and trustees will also need to consider proportionality for different scheme sizes and member demographics.
Good governance, proportionality, appropriate advice and a robust decision-making process remain at the heart of fiduciary duty. This should still be practical and ensure trustees consider the needs of their scheme.”
If you would like to discuss what the draft guidance means for your scheme, including your ESG approach, investment governance and the practical steps trustees should be considering, please get in touch with a member of the TLT Pensions team.
Authors: Amanda Cooke and Lizzie Stone
This publication is intended for general guidance and represents our understanding of the relevant law and practice as at November 2026. Specific advice should be sought for specific cases. For more information see our terms & conditions.
Get in touch
Related services
Get in touch
Insights & events

What the new DWP fiduciary guidance means for your scheme: ESG and trustee actions

AI in Motion: Balanced algorithms - addressing bias in AI

Why work-related stress is a health and safety issue

From intention to action: ESG tips you can use from our podcast guests

Preparing for pension reform: implications for employers

Climate risks and stranded assets: Protecting your property portfolio

Aligning sustainability with opportunity: The business case for biodiversity net gain

Budget 2025 – Pension scheme employers: what do the salary sacrifice changes mean for you?

How can carbon credits and insetting help you achieve your net-zero targets?

AI in Motion - How to make sustainable AI a reality

ESG as part of investment strategies - What pension trustees need to know

Preparing for change: turning the Employment Rights Bill into social ESG advantage

Data beneath the Dashboard: Key data considerations for connecting to Pensions Dashboards

Employee Ownership - How an EOT can support your ESG agenda

Pub and bar: The growing importance of knowing your supply chain

SIPP and SSAS round up: Navigating legal and regulatory change - Autumn 2026

Retail Agility: Navigating the AI frontier in retail

TLT scores hat-trick of nominations at Bristol Law Society Annual Awards Dinner 2024

TLT advises Eolas Architects on transition to employee ownership

TLT advises XPS Pensions Group on National Pension Trust strategic partnership

TLT advises The Guinness Partnership on £400 million real estate joint venture

ESG in Action: Exploring asset finance for business energy projects with Investec

ESG in Action: Pro Bono Week special: How do we improve access to justice?

ESG in Action: The curious workplace: Neuroinclusion at work with Maisie Cass

ESG in Action: Nature recovery in action: What Belmont Estate can teach business

ESG in Action: Where capital meets conservation with Rebalance Earth

ESG in Action: How to work well in high-pressure environments with the Mindful Business Charter

ESG in Action: Turning clauses into climate action with The Chancery Lane Project

ESG in Action: From nice to necessary: The business case for wellbeing

ESG in Action: Financing change and changing finance with Triodos Bank

ESG in Action: Working better with Working Families: Flexibility in the workplace

ESG in Action: The future starts at school: Embedding sustainability early with The Green Britain Foundation

ESG in Action: Inside the Government Legal Department’s social mobility agenda

ESG in Action: Climate resilience in real terms: Breaking sustainability silos with Santander

ESG in Action: Hospitality and sustainability working together for future successes

ESG in Action: Beyond returns: Inside the world of responsible investment

ESG in Action: Trailblazing with Ablaze: Helping young people succeed

Community, connection and collaboration - TLT and Forest Green Rovers FC

Placing sustainability at the heart of learning - TLT and the Ministry of Eco Education

A partnership for sustainable action: TLT and Belmont Estate

BNG - TLT and Belmont Estate talk nature positivity

%20%C3%94%C3%87%C3%B4%20790px%20X%20451px%2072ppi2.jpg)





%20%C3%94%C3%87%C3%B4%20790px%20X%20451px%2072ppi.jpg)




%20%C3%94%C3%87%C3%B4%20790px%20X%20451px%2072ppi%20copy21.jpg)

















