Crichel Down Rules reform: what the proposals mean for local authorities

The government is consulting on a significant overhaul of the Crichel Down Rules (the Rules). For the first time, local authorities could face an expectation — rather than merely a recommendation — of compliance. Here's what could be changing and what you may need to prepare for.

What are the Crichel Down Rules?

The Rules apply where land acquired by a government department using, or under threat of, compulsory purchase powers is declared surplus and a decision is made to sell it. The Rules provide the arrangements governing whether, and on what terms, former owners should be offered the opportunity to buy back land before it is disposed of on the open market.

The Rules originate from a 1954 Parliamentary inquiry into the compulsory purchase of agricultural land at Crichel Down in Dorset by the Air Ministry for use as a bombing range, following which landowners were assured their land would be returned to them when it was no longer required for military purposes. This assurance, however, was not honoured and the Air Ministry transferred the land to another body, thereby putting the market value of the land well beyond the means of the original owners. The resulting inquiry issued the Crichel Down Rules to ensure the fair administration of the disposal of surplus land acquired by, or under threat of, use of a compulsory purchase power.

The Rules have developed piecemeal over several years and have not been subject to a comprehensive review in decades. They are perceived by government departments, agencies and other stakeholders as complex, cumbersome and outdated, with excessive administrative costs.

The government has opened a consultation seeking the views of stakeholders on a range of proposals aimed at consolidating, modernising and reducing the administrative costs of the Crichel Down Rules process.

The proposals

From recommended to expected compliance

Currently, Rule 4 of the Rules only recommends that local authorities and other statutory bodies not subject to ministerial direction (for example, statutory undertakers) follow the Rules. This differs from the position for central government bodies, which are expected to follow the Rules. The government considers that this non-binding position has resulted in uncertainty as to whether, and how, the Rules apply, leading to inconsistent approaches.

The proposed reform would update the Rules so that local authorities and statutory bodies not subject to ministerial direction would be expected (rather than merely recommended) to comply with the Rules.

For local authorities, it is important to understand how the Rules are currently reflected in disposal processes, and where those processes may need to change.

A more streamlined regime?

The government considers that the Rules, while important in promoting fairness, have become complex, cumbersome and costly to administer. Its proposals are intended to enable surplus public land to be disposed of more efficiently and cost-effectively, while maintaining fairness for former owners and ensuring compatibility with the duty to secure the best price reasonably obtainable.

For local authorities, the proposals pull in two directions. They would bring authorities more firmly within the Rules, but at the same time make the Rules themselves more proportionate and, in a number of areas, easier to administer.

So what could the proposed changes mean in practice?

Clearer rules on the "threat of" compulsion

One area that can currently cause difficulty is deciding whether land acquired voluntarily was actually acquired "under threat of compulsion".

Under the proposals, the Rules would apply in those circumstances only where a compulsory purchase power existed at the time of a voluntary sale and the acquiring authority had actively initiated compulsory purchase procedures. Merely having statutory powers available would not be enough.

This should provide greater certainty when authorities are reviewing how land was originally acquired and reduce the scope for this issue to delay a subsequent disposal.

A clearer position on leasehold disposals

The proposals would also change which property interests are caught by the Rules. Currently, the creation and disposal of leasehold interests of more than seven years fall within their scope. The government proposes that the Rules should apply only to the disposal of freehold interests, on the basis that where land is disposed of by way of a new lease, it would not be truly surplus.

Clearer cut-off points for historic acquisitions

The proposals would introduce new time-based limits on the obligation to offer back agricultural land. The general obligation to offer back would not apply to agricultural land which becomes surplus more than 25 years after the date of acquisition, or non-agricultural land which becomes surplus more than 15 years after the date of acquisition. This introduces a single, simplified time horizon for each land type.

For authorities with long-held estates, these clearer cut-off points could provide welcome certainty, particularly when dealing with historic acquisitions, where records may be limited.

Greater freedom to apply exceptions

Some existing exceptions can only be invoked on specific ministerial authority. The government considers this resource-intensive, time-consuming and often disproportionate to the value of the land concerned.

The proposal is to replace that requirement with a "decision of the disposing authority". This should provide greater flexibility and better reflect how disposing authorities operate in practice.

It will, however, make authorities' own decision-making and governance processes increasingly important.

A more workable route for disposals between public bodies

There is currently an exception to the obligation to offer back surplus land to former owners where, for reasons of public interest, it should be disposed of to a local authority or other body that could have acquired it using compulsory purchase powers. In practice, disposing authorities can be reluctant to confirm that those powers would have been used.

The proposed reform would allow land to be disposed of to a local authority or other public sector body where it intends to use the land for a statutory activity or function. Crucially, that purpose would not need to be the same purpose for which the land was originally acquired. The requirements relating to "for reasons of public interest" and disposal "as soon as practicable" would also be removed.

For authorities looking at opportunities to transfer land within the public sector, this could make the exception significantly more workable.

A more proportionate approach to small or low-value parcels

Complying with the current disposal process, particularly where the former owner's identity or address is unknown, can be costly. This is before legal and surveying costs are taken into account, and the overall cost can exceed the market value of the land itself.

The proposed reform would strengthen the existing exception so that the obligation to offer back would not apply where the overall costs of disposing the land in accordance with the Rules are likely to materially exceed the disposing authority's estimated value of the land. This could make a meaningful difference for authorities managing portfolios containing small or low-value parcels, where the cost of compliance is disproportionate to the value involved.

Shorter timescales where former owners can be traced

The government is also proposing to shorten some of the timescales within the offer-back process. Former owners currently have two months to indicate an intention to repurchase and, if they do, a further two months to agree non-financial terms. Those periods would each reduce to one month. The existing flexibility to extend timescales where reasonable would remain. For authorities dealing with surplus land, this could shorten the route through the offer-back process.

Modernising tracing and notification requirements

The government is proposing to modernise the current procedure for tracing former owners. Instead of being expected first to contact the professional representative who acted for the former owner, disposing authorities would be required to undertake reasonable endeavours to locate a current address. If those enquiries were unsuccessful, the requirements to publish notices in the London Gazette, Estates Gazette, Farmers Weekly and local newspapers, and to notify adjacent landowners, would be removed.

A separate proposal would remove the requirement to notify former owners where an authority decides that an exception applies. Instead, the decision would need to be recorded in the central record or file that the authority is already required to maintain.

Together, these measures should reduce some of the administrative burden of the current process. They also underline the importance of authorities maintaining a clear audit trail of how decisions under the Rules have been reached.

Technical changes

Alongside the principal reform proposals, the consultation also seeks views on technical changes to the Rules, including:

  1. Standardising terminology throughout the Rules, replacing "acquiring department", "disposing body" and "disposing department" with the single term "disposing authority".
  2. Codifying the finding in R. v Secretary of State for Defence, Ex parte Wilkins [2000] 3 E.G.L.R. 11 to clarify that the assessment of "material change" in character applies to the whole of the land subject to disposal and not to individual, separate parcels.
  3. Clarifying that the updated Rules do not apply to land acquired by a disposing authority under adverse possession.
  4. Introducing a definition of "agricultural land" by reference to section 109 of the Agriculture Act 1947 to ensure consistent application of the time horizon provisions.
  5. Clarifying the definition of "former owner" under current Rule 13, particularly where the former owner was a business or a public body whose responsibilities have been devolved to another body.
  6. Including formal definitions for "current market value" and "market value" within the Rules themselves, with market value defined as "the best price reasonably obtainable for the surplus land", equivalent to the RICS Red Book definition but including "Special Value" available from a special purchaser.

What should local authorities be thinking about now?

The proposals remain subject to consultation. If they are taken forward, local authorities can expect the Rules to become a more formal part of their disposal processes, even if the Rules themselves become simpler to apply.

Authorities should consider:

  • Reviewing existing disposal procedures to understand how potential Crichel Down issues are currently identified and dealt with;
  • Identifying historic acquisitions within the disposal pipeline where the proposed 15 and 25 year cut-off periods could make a difference;
  • Checking whether acquisition records capture how land was originally acquired, particularly where there may have been a threat of compulsory purchase;
  • Considering whether current governance and record-keeping arrangements would support more formal application of the Rules, including documenting decisions to rely on an exception; and
  • Deciding whether there are aspects of the proposals on which to respond to the consultation, particularly where the changes could have a practical impact on estates and disposal programmes.

The consultation opened on 4 November 2026, closes at 23:59 on 6 January 2027 and can be found here.

TLT advises both authorities and landowners in respect of the application and claims pursuant to the Rules. We can help authorities understand what the proposed changes could mean for their disposal processes, historic acquisitions and land portfolios. For further advice or guidance, please contact Debbie Reynolds or James Mallery-Nelson.

This publication is intended for general guidance and represents our understanding of the relevant law and practice as at November 2026. Specific advice should be sought for specific cases. For more information see our terms & conditions.

Written by
James Mallery-Nelson
Written by
Debbie Reynolds
Date published
18 Nov 2026

Abstract overlapping curved shapes in varying shades of violet and purple on a solid violet background.

Legal insights & events

Keep up to date on the issues that matter.

Abstract yellow background with overlapping translucent olive green curved shapes.

Follow us

Find us on social media

No items found.